Class Action Lawsuit Filed Against SoCal Edison for Thomas Fire and Mudslide Damages

Class Action Lawsuit Filed Against SoCal Edison for Thomas Fire and Mudslide Damages title=
Class Action Lawsuit Filed Against SoCal Edison for Thomas Fire and Mudslide Damages
25 Comments
Reads 7513

Source: Lieff Cabraser Heimann & Bernstein

Lieff Cabraser Heimann & Bernstein LLP, Cappello & Noël LLP, and Keller Rohrback LLP announce that Victoria Frost d/b/a Frost Fit and  seven other plaintiffs have filed a class action lawsuit in Los Angeles Superior Court against Southern California Edison Company and Edison International for personal and business losses from the 2017-2018 Thomas Fire and Mudslides that occurred as a result of SCE’s alleged failure to properly and safely maintain its electrical infrastructure in Santa Barbara and Ventura Counties.

The Thomas Fire, Large-Scale Evacuations, and Lives Lost

Starting on or about December 4, 2017, a fire began raging in the mountains and steep slopes surrounding Lake Casitas and the City of Ojai in Santa Barbara and Ventura Counties. Driven by the Santa Ana winds, the fire consumed over 280,000 acres, including large portions of the Los Padres National Forest. Ash from the fire covered the land like a gray snow, and smoke filled the air and brought a dark pall over the sky. Over 100,000 residents were required to evacuate and two lives were lost.

The Thomas fire burned an area larger than New York City, Washington D.C., and San Francisco combined. At the height of its strength, the Thomas Fire qualified as a “firestorm,” meaning it was strong enough to create its own weather. At times, the fire advanced at a rate of an acre per second.

Fighting the Thomas Fire required the largest mobilization of firefighters for combating any wildfire in California history. More than 8,500 came from all over the United States and other parts of the world to combat the flames. The areas affected by the Thomas Fire were declared a national disaster by the President in January. The Thomas Fire burned more than 281,000 acres, destroyed 1,063 structures, including 775 homes, and damaged another 280 before it was finally contained on January 12, 2018. The California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection (“Cal Fire”) determined the Thomas Fire was both the largest fire in California’s modern history, as well as the seventh most destructive.

Massive Mudslides, at Least 21 Residents Killed

The Thomas Fire denuded the landscape of the dense thickets of chaparral, brush, and tall grass that normally cover the region. When rain arrived, the destruction from the Thomas Fire triggered mudslides by turning hundreds miles of the Santa Ynez Mountains into precarious, unstable ground capable of being swept away at any moment. Additionally, because the Fire burned so intensely, the soil was transformed into a dense, water-repellant surface. The U.S. Geological Survey warned of the high risk for disastrous landslides if heavy rain fell on mountainsides around Santa Barbara that had been scorched by the Thomas wildfire.

On January 9, 2018 massive flows of mud tumbled down mountain slopes laid bare by the massive fire. Car-sized boulders and trees rushed through the area on a devastating rampage. Massive flows of debris, comprised of mud as thick as concrete and moving at speeds of up to 20 miles per hour, slammed into the neighborhoods below. Some homes were ripped from their foundations while others were swallowed by waist-high mud and rubble. Over 20 million pounds of debris have been removed thus far, and trucks continue to haul thousands of pounds each day. At least twenty-one people, including children, were killed, and more than 400 homes were destroyed or damaged. Rescue crews continue to search for two missing people, a 2 year old and a 17 year old.

“It's hard to describe the damage these fires and mudslides caused without sounding apocalyptic,” said Lieff Cabraser's Robert Nelson, one of the attorneys who filed the complaint. “Walls of mud crashing through neighborhoods and homes at the speed of cars, fire devastation and deaths that never should have happened had Southern California Edison honored its duties to properly build, inspect, and maintain its power lines and electrical equipment.”

Santa Barbara, Montecito, Carpinteria Most Directly Affected

The area hardest hit by the mudslides was Montecito, a small community nestled between the Santa Ynez Mountains and the Pacific Ocean that was just below the Thomas Fire but had been spared by its flames. The small oceanside city of Carpinteria was also affected.  U.S. Highway 101, the main artery from Santa Barbara to points east, was covered by the mudslides, and remained closed for over ten days, severely restricting access to and from the area and causing businesses to close or go without customers and employees.

The class action complaint alleges that the Thomas Fire and related mudslides disasters have a common underlying cause, that they were sparked by unsafe electrical infrastructure owned, operated, and improperly maintained by Southern California Edison Company and Edison International (hereinafter “SCE”). The complaint notes that SCE had a duty to maintain its electrical infrastructure properly and to ensure surrounding trees and vegetation were trimmed and kept at a safe distance, and that SCE violated that duty by knowingly operating aging, overloaded, and/or improperly maintained infrastructure.

In fact, SCE’s violations have caused fires before, and SCE has been sanctioned numerous times for such violations previous to the Thomas Fire. As the complaint further alleges, SCE has throughout the time before and leading up to the Thomas Fire knowingly and habitually underestimated the potential risk, including fire risk, that its systems posed. Had SCE acted responsibly, the devastating Thomas Fire and subsequent lethal and destructive mudslides could have been prevented.

“It is heartbreaking to consider that the losses and deaths suffered by the victims of the Thomas Fire and mudslides could have been prevented had SCE upheld its duties to its customers and adequately and safely maintained its electrical infrastructure as mandated by law,” notes Lexi Hazam, another Lieff Cabraser partner filing the case. “We hope our lawsuit will provide justice to those devastated by the fires and mudslides, and help raise awareness of the serious fire dangers and related other dangers still present in thousands of similar Southern California Edison works and systems throughout Southern California.”

The Complaint notes that plaintiffs have suffered property damage, economic losses, and disruption to their homes, businesses, lives, and livelihoods, and they seek fair compensation for themselves in this case. They also bring this case as a class action, because they believe all those who suffered such damages and losses should be fairly treated and included as beneficiaries of a comprehensive and consistent adjudication or resolution of liability and damages. Plaintiffs bring claims on behalf of themselves and all others similarly situated for damages for, inter alia, damage to and loss of use of real and personal property; loss of income; loss of business; consequential and incidental damages; emotional distress; and other harm caused by the defendants’ wrongful conduct.

The Plaintiffs and Their Losses

Robert Blanchard and Victoria Frost are husband and wife residents of Santa Barbara County. Ms. Frost d/b/a Frost Fit is an independent contractor who works as a nutritionist and fitness consultant primarily out of the Coral Casino Beach and Cabana Club (“Coral Casino”) in Montecito. Because of the Thomas Fire, the Coral Casino was evacuated and Ms. Frost was unable to work. Just as the orders had been lifted, the Coral Casino was affected by the Mudslides, and yet again, she was not able to work with her clients. The Coral Casino remains closed at the time of this filing and does not expect to reopen until April 1, 2018. Mr. Blanchard is a contractor who works for himself. The Thomas Fire burned down the project he was building.

Martha Smilgis is a resident of Santa Barbara County who owns a residence in Montecito that was damaged by the mudslides, including by mud breaking through a window and a tree crashing through her front door. The mudslides also filled the home with the contents of homes higher up the hill. It now contains the books, clothing, and pieces of plumbing of her neighbors.

Diane Meehan d/b/a Dadiana Inc. is a resident of Santa Barbara County and the sole proprietor of Diadana Inc., a salon in Montecito she has owned and worked in for the past 20 years. The Thomas Fire forced the closure of her business for two weeks, and just as she was to return to work the mudslides hit, forcing further closures. She has yet to be able to return to her salon and has been forced to rent space from another salon in order to do any work. Her home in Carpinteria has also been damaged by smoke and ash from the Thomas Fire.

Platinum Performance Fitness, Inc., d/b/a Platinum Fitness Summerland, is a California corporation. It operates a gym located in Summerland, Santa Barbara County, owned by Peter Park and Kelly Park, husband and wife and residents of Santa Barbara County.  Peter Park is a nationally recognized personal trainer with clients in Santa Barbara and Los Angeles. When the Thomas Fire hit, Platinum Fitness Summerland was closed down under an evacuation order. Approximately 80% of the gym’s clients are from Montecito, which was hit hard by the fire and was also under mandatory evacuation orders. In addition, the air quality was so poor that no clients wanted to train. Following the fire, the gym was again placed under mandatory shut down after the flood, mudslides, and Highway 101 closure. In addition, the Parks were under a mandatory evacuation order from their Santa Barbara home during the Thomas Fire, and suffered damages in having to evacuate, and their home suffered ash and smoke damage.

Honhai, Inc., is a California corporation doing business as the China Pavilion at Chapala, a restaurant in Santa Barbara City. It is owned by Santa Barbara County residents and husband and wife, Lisa Lee and Peter Chen. The Thomas Fire hit as holiday parties and catered events were just starting, and caused the cancellation of many events as well as a severe drop in business due to the conditions surrounding the fire as well as recurrent power outages and subsequent evacuations and road closures due to the mudslides.

Thomas E. Carroll is a resident of Santa Barbara County, and the sole proprietor of his personal business driving residents of Montecito and Santa Barbara, frequently including trips throughout Southern California. When the Thomas Fire hit, most of his clients evacuated, and deteriorated visibility conditions led most others to avoid traveling, leading to a drastic drop in business. Since the mudslide-caused highway closures, Mr. Carroll’s business has been virtually nonexistent.

Christopher T. Burke is a personal trainer and a Santa Barbara County resident. Operating primarily out of Platinum Fitness Gym in Summerland, he also travels to corporations and client homes. The Thomas Fire reduced air quality so severely that no clients wanted to train, many leaving town entirely. Mr. Burke’s work was reduced drastically before Platinum Fitness was shut entirely under a mandatory evacuation order. When the air quality improved available work began to return, only to disappear when the mudslides hit Montecito and evacuation was reimposed, cutting Mr. Burke off from 70% of his income.

Read a copy of the Complaint.

Learn more about Lieff Cabraser’s work on the Southern California Fires and Mudslides cases.

The Class Action Claims

The lawsuit is brought by the named plaintiffs alleging class claims on behalf of individuals and entities worked in, or owned or leased real or personal property within the California counties of Santa Barbara or Ventura (the “Fire and Mudslides Area”); California entities that owned, operated, or leased a physical facility in the Fire and Mudslides Area and sold products directly to consumers or end users or regularly purchased products from the Fire and Mudslides Area to produce goods for resale, or provided services while physically present in the Fire and Mudslides Area, or owned or leased real property in the Fires and Mudslides Area.

The lawsuit seeks compensation for plaintiffs’ real and personal property losses, loss of wages and earning capacity, business profits, displacement expenses, and punitive damages, among other claims. Read a copy of the Complaint.

Login to add Comments

25 Comments

Toggle Comments (Show)
a-1534237245 Mar 28, 2018 07:08 PM
Class Action Lawsuit Filed Against SoCal Edison for Thomas Fire and Mudslide Damages

So, Montecito residents are blaming everyone but themselves for these tragedies. Fire. Landslides. Wrongful death(s). Inevitable that they would, given the wealth and plethora of attorney and other professional residents affected by this tragedy. The rest of us recognize that California is a HIGHLY geologically active place. That Climate Change is real and that prolonged drought and excessive heat cause fires. That burned land causes water to runoff. That Montecito, at the base of mountains and filled with creeks, IS A FLOODPLAIN. They were warned multiple times. Failed to heed the warnings. Died or lost loved ones as a result. And are now filing suit against those with perceived “deep pockets” (those would be OURS, folks) to recoup their losses. What an abysmally immature group of self-important, entitled nitwits. YOU CHOSE TO RESIDE/DO BUSINESS THERE, Montecitans. Buck up, accept that you made possibly the biggest error of your lives in choosing to do so. It is not the “fault” of anyone nor any entity. It’s nature, geology, fate. Kindly do not make ALL of us pay for your gigantic errors in the forms of drastic increases in our utility bills, taxes, etc.

WoopWoop Jan 27, 2018 11:05 AM
Class Action Lawsuit Filed Against SoCal Edison for Thomas Fire and Mudslide Damages

Many, many people in Santa Barbara and Ventura counties were impacted by these events. I am proud of our community - most responded with grace, compassion, generosity and gratitude. I consider myself extraordinarily lucky with only smoke, ash and financial losses. These businesses and their self-centered owners are lame.

Luvaduck Jan 27, 2018 10:21 AM
Class Action Lawsuit Filed Against SoCal Edison for Thomas Fire and Mudslide Damages

Does everyone get that when utilities are sued, the cost of defending themselves and whatever damages are awarded do not come out of the salaries of the people who make/made the decisions or workers who screwed up? They come out of utility-user pockets in the form of higher rates or less service. Same with suits against municipalities or police departments and so forth. Either higher taxes, deficit spending, deferred maintenance or service reductions.

a-1534237245 Jan 26, 2018 03:54 PM
Class Action Lawsuit Filed Against SoCal Edison for Thomas Fire and Mudslide Damages

This is laughable and why people hate lawyers. Sad really. I mean, what is SCE supposed to do in a perfect storm like a huge wind event and a drought? Should SCE have foreseen that? I mean, people want to live in these fire prone areas and demand electricity, what do you expect? Don't come to the risk if you don't want to deal with the consequencs of that risk. Maybe we should start banning people from rebuilding in these fireprone areas if this is how people are going to act.

a-1534237245 Jan 26, 2018 04:36 PM
Class Action Lawsuit Filed Against SoCal Edison for Thomas Fire and Mudslide Damages

PDW - Good point and great analogy. But, I meant to address the specific point of SCE being liable for the results of the flood/debris flow. Yes, liability to these personal trainers and chauffeur may be minor and the nerve of them to be suing at this point is disgusting. But, I just wanted to point out the overall liability issues related to SCE and the debris flow resulting from the fire they may have caused.

a-1534237245 Jan 26, 2018 04:00 PM
Class Action Lawsuit Filed Against SoCal Edison for Thomas Fire and Mudslide Damages

Not sure you get it really. SCE is not responsible for the storm, they may be responsible for the Thomas Fire though. If so, then everything that happens as a result of that fire (in this case, the deadly debris flow) is their fault. It's really basic. If I break my neighbor's fence and thier dog runs out into traffic and causes an accident, who do you think is at fault? Me or the neighbor's dog for running out of its formerly enclosed yard? Who caused the chain of events leading to the damage/loss. This is what proximate cause and all the laws of causation and negligence are about. I

a-1534237245 Jan 26, 2018 01:38 PM
Class Action Lawsuit Filed Against SoCal Edison for Thomas Fire and Mudslide Damages

I get down voted for pointing out that those who cause loss of life and/or property to another person should be able to hold accountable the person who is responsible for their loss, due to that persons carelessness??? Ok, keep living in your dreamland where no one is responsible for their actions.....SMH.

a-1534237245 Jan 26, 2018 03:04 PM
Class Action Lawsuit Filed Against SoCal Edison for Thomas Fire and Mudslide Damages

THEREALBEBE - I 100% agree. I did not read the full article and was shocked to see the majority of plaintiff's are suing for business losses. THAT is despicable. However, anyone who lost property, family members, etc should have the right to sue the responsible party, whoever that may be, without the judgement of online posters here.

therealbebe Jan 26, 2018 02:13 PM
Class Action Lawsuit Filed Against SoCal Edison for Thomas Fire and Mudslide Damages

Loss of life and property, absolutely. But the majority of people in this suit did NOT lose any of the above. Their incomes suffered - newsflash, hundreds of businesses were and still are impacted by this. Does that mean every single person who couldn't go to work should sue? What gets me is the trainers and chauffer. Literally mobile businesses.

therealbebe Jan 26, 2018 01:04 PM
Class Action Lawsuit Filed Against SoCal Edison for Thomas Fire and Mudslide Damages

Shame on you. I would expect to see lawsuits like this from people who have actually lost their homes and FAMILIES. But personal trainers and a chauffer crying about loss of income? Literally thousands of people either couldn't work or lost business - should they all join this lawsuit as well? Ridiculous.

PdW Jan 26, 2018 12:36 PM
Class Action Lawsuit Filed Against SoCal Edison for Thomas Fire and Mudslide Damages

This lawsuit was filed on the Friday after the storm...they were literally still pulling people out of the mud when this lawsuit was filed. There was no attempt to even determine damages, let alone deal with insurance in any real capacity yet. There is obviously a time and place legal action, but to me this is egregious. There were so many stories and examples of people coming together in our community to help each other...this is the flip side, and while the lawyers won't feel bad...the people filing this should!

a-1534237245 Jan 26, 2018 02:14 PM
Class Action Lawsuit Filed Against SoCal Edison for Thomas Fire and Mudslide Damages

You are correct, it’s a different lawsuit (my mistake). That being said, it still seems crazy to me that 15 days after the storm (and 3 days after the freeway opens) the lawsuit is filed. That means the lawyers have been preparing it for at least a few days and the plaintiffs came to them at least a week ago... right? That’s mind boggling to me. I think these plaintiffs should be ashamed of themselves... As a lifelong Santa barbarism I’m ashamed for them!

mrtrump Jan 26, 2018 10:59 AM
Class Action Lawsuit Filed Against SoCal Edison for Thomas Fire and Mudslide Damages

If it is determined that So Cal Edison caused the fire, then all electrical utilities should be banned from California. An immediate moratorium should be placed on all new electrical infrastructure, electrical hookup permits and land leasing for electrical utilities. All electrical utility infrastructure should be removed from government owned lands (City, county state and federal). All new infrastructure bringing electricity into the state should be made illegal. In other words, treat the electrical industry just like we treat the oil and gas industry in the State of California.

a-1534237245 Jan 26, 2018 11:04 AM
Class Action Lawsuit Filed Against SoCal Edison for Thomas Fire and Mudslide Damages

Richyrich, I totally understand your loathe for lawyers in situation like this, but think of the victims. If the negligence and carelessness of a utility company was the direct cause of their losses, why shouldn't they be able to sue for damages? That's why we have these laws. You screw up and cause someone harm/damage/loss, you are responsible for making them whole again. It's really pretty simple.

Please Login or Register to comment on this.