Montecito Mudslide Victims File Wrongful Death Lawsuits
Families and victims affected by the January 9th debris flow have filed wrongful death lawsuits against Southern California Edison.
On Thursday, March 29 at 11 a.m., attorneys with Panish Shea & Boyle LLP and the Wildfire Victim Advocates legal group held a press conference in Montecito to announce the filing of the lawsuit against Southern California Edison (SCE) on behalf of the victims of the Montecito Mudslides.
Plaintiffs include Santa Barbara County resident and mother Carie Baker-Corey who was swept away with her twin daughters Summer and Sawyer Corey (both 12) and their half-sister Morgan Corey (25) by fast-moving debris flow that demolished their Montecito home. Morgan and Sawyer were both killed in the catastrophic mudslide. Carie and Summer were later found in critical condition and continue on their long road to recovery.
“It was like an avalanche, coming at 100 mph, breaking through our home and forcing us down the creek" recalls Carie Baker-Corey. "We were holding hands as long as we could. I'll never forget the look of terror on Morgan's face as she was pulled under & disappeared."
The law firms of Panish Shea & Boyle LLP, Walkup, Melodia, Kelly & Schoenberger, Cotchett, Pitre & McCarthy LLP and Rogers Sheffield & Campbell have joined forces and resources to investigate and prosecute claims in which they feel SCE is responsible.
According to the law firms, the Los Angeles County-based utility company knew about the significant risk of wildfires stemming from its unsafe equipment, aging infrastructure, and ineffective vegetation management system for many years before the Thomas Fire began, and has been repeatedly fined or cited for failing to mitigate these risks. The Thomas Fire and mudslides were the inevitable byproducts of SCE's willful and conscious disregard of public safety, they said in a public statement.
SCE responded by stating, "The Thomas fire has obviously had an impact on many individuals, but the origin and cause of the fire continue to be under investigation and no report has yet been issued. This and other lawsuits are not based on findings related to an investigation. Therefore, it would be premature for SCE to comment on the origin or cause of the wildfire.”
The press conference announcing this lawsuit is available below courtesy of KEYT News.
A separate wrongful death lawsuit was filed Wednesday in Santa Barbara Superior Court against SCE.
Ralph "Lalo" Barajas lost his partner Peter Fleurat and the home they shared in the debris flow on January 9th. His attorneys allege SCE's faulty electrical equipment created the conditions that lead to the Thomas Fire and the deadly mudslide in Montecito.
Representing Fleurat's family are attorneys Alexander Robertson IV, of Westlake Village; Peter Bezek, of Foley Bezek Behle & Curtis LLP in Santa Barbara; Joseph Liebman of Santa Barbara; and Geoff Spreter of San Diego. In total, 17 lawsuits have been filed on behalf of 250 victims from the Thomas Fire and Montecito mudslide, reports KEYT.
Past Articles
January 26, 2018: Class Action Lawsuit Filed Against SoCal Edison for Thomas Fire and Montecito Mudslide Damages
February 2, 2018: Remembering Peter Fleurat
Comments Penalty Box
3 Comments deleted due to down vote
1 Comments deleted by Administrator
29 Comments
-
4
-
2
-
Mar 29, 2018 12:11 PMIt is definitely part of our American Culture for a feeding frenzy to begin when there is a little blood in the water. The attorneys started licking their chops when the fire was burning and definitely began their war dance on January 9th. Remember, THEY ARE JUST SUING YOU AND I. IF they get an award from SCE, it just means that YOUR electricity rates are going up for the rest of your children's lives. It is hard to look at any of this calamity as anything but an "Act of God". 70+ mph winds in Ventura County is almost guaranteed to send some sort of roofing or tree parts into a power line and start a fire... period. And the really sad thing is that the only winner of a lawsuit like this is the ATTORNEYS, not the clients. There is always very little left for the victims after the attorneys take their cut and pay their expenses. I feel very deeply sad for the people that lost family and property, but this really is not going to make it all better.
-
3
-
-
Mar 29, 2018 12:14 PMI see your point but... what if SoCal Edison is actually at fault. Shouldn't they be held accountable?
-
2
-
2
-
Mar 29, 2018 12:19 PMExactly - if SCE is at fault, what do all you anti-lawyers out there think? Do we let them skirt liability just because you don't like lawyers? And again, YETI, the "70+ mph winds" were caused by the fire, not the other way around. We don't get 70 mph wind here. We get fires that drive wind into frenzies like this due to the massive heat and wind coming off the fire, but not the other way around. Acts of God are tornadoes, earthquakes, etc.... A massive wildfire sparked by SCE's faulty equipment (if this is found to be the actual cause) is NOT an "act of God," it is an act of negligence. When you screw up, you pay for the damages. It's simple.
-
2
-
2
-
Mar 29, 2018 12:23 PMSELF EDIT: Oops, my bad! The 70 mph winds were driving the fire. But, that doesn't change the theory that, if SCE's equipment was the cause of the spark that ignited the fire, then SCE should be liable.
-
5
-
2
-
Mar 29, 2018 12:39 PMDoesn't really matter if they are at fault or not. They will NOT pay for a settlement or a loss in court. WE, those with electric bills, will be the lucky people paying for the settlement with higher rates for many years to come. I did a little digging and found nothing about SCE being fined many times in the past for poor maintenance or neglect for brush removal. If they did or not, it is still an Act of God - can't sue Mother Nature.
-
2
-
1
-
Mar 29, 2018 12:53 PMApparently you did not "dig" very hard for evidence of SCE being punished for faulty equipment. A simple Google search brought this LA Times article up, "Power lines and electrical equipment are a leading cause of California wildfires," http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-utility-wildfires-20171017-story.html__________ In it, the article states that "regulators have hit the state's investor-owned utilities with tens of millions of dollars in fines related to wildfires, including $37 million for the 2007 Malibu fire (Southern California Edison);........"___________ So, the whole "Act of God" theory about fires just "happening" is kind of silly, you think?
Comment has been deleted by edhat
Comment has been deleted by edhat
-
1
-
2
-
Mar 29, 2018 12:50 PMI would not sue but I would like to be paid back for my loved ones as far as I'm concerned that would be like their actions killed my loved ones I would think it would make them more than acceptable toward covering my loss there would be alternatives though.
-
1
-
2
-
Mar 30, 2018 09:35 AMYou would first need to explain why you ignored evacuation warnings along with knowledge about your own property location risks that left your own family in peril.
-
-
-
Mar 31, 2018 02:11 PMI don't think that's quite fair, Factotum. There were voluntary evacuation zones during the Thomas Fire. I was in one. I was also downtown, and figured a whole city would pretty much need to burn before the fire got to me. So I stayed, figuring my risks were low. I remember how fast the Painted Cave fire moved, but in this case, I knew the firefighters were at the top, defending the first line of structures. I bet that I'd be ok, and my bet turned out to be correct. Those in the voluntary evacuation zones before 1/8/18 probably looked at the weather map, have been thru storms before and not slid, made a similar calculus, and unfortunately, their bet was wrong. Sheriff Brown summed it up right: people heard 'voluntary', not 'evacuation'.
-
7
-
2
-
Mar 29, 2018 03:51 PMThose that have suffered extreme losses from this geologic/atmospheric tragedy are grasping at straws, and are encouraged by ambulance chasing lawyers. What has happened is the geologic reality of living in this area, nothing more. It was peaceful for many decades, but not now. Will Edison be blamed for the 8-9 earthquake when it finally hits? Probably!
-
2
-
4
-
Mar 29, 2018 04:25 PMSCE and PGE have been negligent for DECADES in maintaining their infrastructure and have thus been the cause of Billions of taxpayer dollars fighting large conflagration fires over the years... I hope they get SLAMMED and their Management Teams no longer receive the Hundreds of Millions of dollars in annual "bonuses" because of it.
The Public Utility Commission has dropped the ball on holding these monopoly power companies for upgrading and maintaining their infrastructure that runs through our public lands--- HAMMER THEM HARD!
-
2
-
2
-
Mar 30, 2018 09:34 AMSCE is a pubic utility- if you "slam them hard" you are the one picking up the bill. Plus there were illegal drug camp raids in that exact same area only a month prior, one mile from the Thomas Aquinas campus. Any connection to finding hot plates and gas fired generators in those very same illegal drug camps?
Comment has been deleted by edhat
-
2
-
2
-
Mar 29, 2018 04:54 PMsadly, these lawyers saw money signs when this happened. Its not because they care.
Im guessing they are getting atleast 40% of the settlement for "taking the case". If they can prove edison's neglect caused the fire, and later flooding. Then I hope the victims will get some closure and most of the settlement, but seeing the advertisements for "flood lawyers" on facebook make me think that isnt going to happen. I hope those affected find a way to get closure and move on, this could draw out for years and never let the living victims stop thinking about the disaster.
-
1
-
2
-
Mar 30, 2018 09:32 AMMost ot the lawyer ads only say they will "get you what your insurance company owes you". They are only going after the easy money, after taking their own 30% contingency fees.
-
6
-
3
-
Mar 29, 2018 05:01 PMPeople suffered losses (more than you can imagine) and, if these losses were found to be caused by SCE, shouldn't they be made whole again (or at least as much as possible)? I understand all of your frustration with the "ambulance chasers" out there, but please understand there are many lawyers trying to help these people recoup the losses suffered due to SCE's negligence. These lawyers are doing this because it is their job. They work harder than most of you ever have or will in your lives (they certainly don't have time for online comments all day long) and have chosen a hated profession (look at your comments) in order to help others. There are, of course the scum bag lawyers, but they're easy to distinguish. Please try to remember that.
-
1
-
2
-
Mar 29, 2018 09:42 PMThe deaths sadly were caused by people ignoring both common sense and evacuation warnings. Those who lived creekside and in its flood paths had a duty to understand the dangerous conditions they were facing.
-
3
-
2
-
Mar 29, 2018 09:47 PMProperty owners have an obligation to insure their property. Persons living in known hazardous areas have a duty to protect themselves, regardless of official warnings, which in this case were ignored anyway. Insurance will cover property losses. Those who lost family and friends will need to finally make peace with their God.
Comment has been deleted by edhat
Comment has been deleted by edhat
Comment has been deleted by edhat
-
-
-
Mar 31, 2018 09:26 PMI agree! All bad mouthing until something happens in which case you just might want one. I worked for a law office that pursued unfit teachers -- yeah, you can only imagine how bad it really is. I have worked with and met some amazing, committed to moral rules, lawyers. And I do support the ACLU and other organizations that work for those who can't afford lawyers.
-
-
-
Apr 01, 2018 08:48 AMgot it, i wondered what "down vote meant" lol!
-
1
-
1
-
Mar 31, 2018 12:22 PMI'm curious why the debris flow/mudslides didn't happen anywhere but in Montecito, when there was so much acreage burned from Santa Paula to Santa Barbara? How often do the creeks get cleaned in Montecito and what measures were taken to prevent clogs in the case of any event? It appears to be isolated to our areas creeks? A google search for the local 1995 Floods provides a lot of information in any case.
-
3
-
-
Mar 31, 2018 01:20 PMIt's not about preventative maintenance as much as the sheer volume of water dumped on a specific site in a very short period of time. From all accounts the debris flow topped the banks of creeks 2-5 times over, that is creeks with 15ft banks saw a 45ft wall of mud, tree trunks and boulders galloping down hill. You can't plan for such rare weather events or nothing would get done as everything would be overbuilt to the hilt and expensive as all get out.
-
-
-
Mar 31, 2018 01:46 PMI see
-
-
-
Mar 31, 2018 01:46 PMI see, hope something comes from all this.
-
5
-
-
Mar 31, 2018 02:40 PMTopography and and the rate of rainfall per hour or as in this case per 15 minutes.
weather..................
This has been explained many times on the TV news and other sources.
.......................................it's not always the same everywhere
Sort of like why tornadoes and lightning strikes only happen where they happen.
-
-
-
Mar 31, 2018 04:21 PMi guess its just surprising that we were caught off guard when mudslides have happened a few times all ready , 1960's and 1995. I will never forget 1995-
-
1
-
2
-
Mar 31, 2018 04:27 PMcarrie is the most wonderfull and courageos woman i know, i hope sce takes responsibility for its lack of action, sce is worth 45 billion dollars and has an annual income of 700-800 million, ever checked your bills lately...RIP OFF
-
1
-
-
Mar 31, 2018 06:47 PMShe is and so are all the people that were personally affected, what a nightmare .
-
1
-
-
Mar 31, 2018 04:32 PMand another thing, mr. logue is not in it for money..know that for a fact!!!!
-
-
1
-
Apr 01, 2018 08:55 AMDays and days of warnings in advance! Warnings of the potential for catastrophic mudslides! People don't listen! People die! Take some personal responsibility for yourself! Now they want to jump on board with a bunch of rotten lawyers and sue SCE? These people are nothing more than high-class dirtbags!