Identities Released in Orcutt Triple Homicide

Identities Released in Orcutt Triple Homicide title=
Identities Released in Orcutt Triple Homicide
61 Comments
Reads 15735
Update by Santa Barbara County Sheriff's Office
December 31, 2018
 

Additional Details Released on Triple Homicide Case

While many details cannot be released or are yet to be determined due to the ongoing nature of the investigation, the Sheriff’s Office is releasing some additional information on the triple homicide that occurred on December 28, 2018.

The person who called 911 lived at the residence and had returned home to find her friend, victim Nicole McNabb, covered with blood in the bathtub. She fled the home and called for help. Victim Carlos Echavarria also lived at the residence and was a friend of victim Melanie McNabb. The motive for this brutal act of violence is still under investigation and has not been determined. All three victims lived at the residence and were brutally beaten and stabbed. Autopsies are pending but there is no preliminary evidence to indicate that any of the victims were shot. 

Due to his 2014 domestic violence conviction, suspect David McNabb was not legally permitted to own or possess a firearm. Detectives ar e in the process of trying to determine the ownership of the rifle that he was armed with when confronted by deputies. Other than his domestic violence conviction, suspect David McNabb did not appear to have any other criminal history. 

After McNabb was shot by deputies with less lethal munitions, he remained armed and a threat to deputies. A total of two deputies deployed less lethal munitions and four deputies shot at McNabb. An autopsy for David McNabb is scheduled for Thursday, January 3, 2019. 

During the course of the investigation, detectives determined that David McNabb’s younger brother, 40-year-old Brian McNabb of Santa Maria, had previously assaulted another family member at Brian McNabb’s residence in the City of Santa Maria prior to the triple homicide incident on December 28, 2018. On December 30, 2018, Sheriff’s deputies arrested Brian McNabb at his home. He was booked at the Santa Barbara County Jail on charges of battery with serious bodily injury and is being held on $50,000 bail.


Update by Santa Barbara County Sheriff's Office
December 30, 2018

Identities of Homicide Victims and Suspect Released

The Sheriff’s Office has completed next of kin notifications and is releasing the names of three homicide victims and the deceased suspect responsible for the murders. The suspect is 43-year-old David Gerald McNabb of Orcutt. The decedents include his sister, 34-year-old Nicole McNabb of Orcutt, his mother 64-year-old Melanie McNabb of Orcutt and 63-year-old Carlos Echavarria of Orcutt.

David McNabb formerly worked at the Santa Barbara County Sheriff’s Office as a Custody Deputy from July of 2001 to March of 2012, when he voluntarily resigned. In September of 2012 he was arrested by the Oxnard Police Department and booked at the Ventura County Jail. In May of 2014, he was convicted of felony domestic violence and sentenced to jail.

The Sheriff’s Office continues to investigate the motive and circumstances leading up to this horrific act of violence and we send our heartfelt condolences to the family and friends of the victims who were so senselessly killed.

The 2014 booking photo was provided by the Ventura County Sheriff's Office.


Update by Santa Barbara County Sheriff's Office
3:40 p.m., December 29, 2018

Additional Details Released on Triple Homicide and Death of Suspect

The Sheriff’s Office continues to actively investigate a triple homicide that occurred last night, December 28, 2018, at a residence in the 5900 block of Oakhill Road in Orcutt. 

The identities of the victims and the suspect are being withheld until all of the next of kin notifications are complete. Preliminary indications are that the victims all lived at the residence and were brutally stabbed and beaten to death by the suspect, who also lived at the residence. A motive for this deadly rampage is unknown at this time and is under investigation.

In addition to the investigation into the murders, the Sheriff’s Office is also conducting an officer involved shooting investigation. Deputies with the Sheriff’s Special Enforcement Team used less lethal munitions (40mm impact weapon and shotgun beanbag rounds) in an attempt to subdue the armed suspect. However, the suspect continued to pose an immediate threat, at which point the deputies shot him. Despite life-saving efforts by paramedics, the suspect succumbed to his injuries and was pronounced dead at a local hospital. 

Sheriff’s Detectives and Forensics personnel have been working around the clock to process the crime scene and gather evidence. We will provide additional details once next of kin notifications have been finalized, as the investigation unfolds and as facts are confirmed.


Update by Santa Barbara County Sheriff's Office
2:00 a.m., December 29, 2018

Triple Homicide Investigation in Orcutt

At approximately 8:05 p.m. last night, December 28, 2018, the Santa Barbara County Public Safety Dispatch Center received a call from a person who had entered her home in the 5900 block of Oakhill Rd. and found a bloody scene inside. She discovered a victim covered in blood in a bathtub, fled the residence and called for help. When responding deputies arrived at the Oakhill Estates residence they determined that a suspect was inside. Deputies entered the home, contacted the suspect and determined that he was armed with a rifle. An emergency notification was sent to residents in Oakhill Estates advising them to shelter in place. The Sheriff’s Special Enforcement Team (SET) and Sheriff’s Hostage Negotiation Team were called to the scene.

Further information was obtained from the suspect that there were additional people inside the house. In an effort to rescue any potential victims, Sheriff’s SET deputies made further entry into the house. They made contact with the armed suspect, a confrontation ensued during which the suspect was initially shot with less lethal munitions, followed by the use of deadly force. The suspect was transported to a hospital by ambulance and was subsequently pronounced dead.

When deputies searched the residence, they found a total of three deceased persons inside believed to be homicide victims. The names of these victims and the suspect are being withheld until all are positively identified and next of kin has been notified.

This tragic incident remains under active investigation. Accordingly, no additional information will be released until further notice.


Reported by Roger the Scanner Guy
8:32 p.m., December 28, 2018

Suspicious circumstances man with a rifle..North County possibly 5900 Block of Oak Hill Drive..

Login to add Comments

61 Comments

Toggle Comments (Show)
a-1566566100 Jan 01, 2019 02:09 AM
Identities Released in Orcutt Triple Homicide

Those McNabb brothers sound like pure trouble. It is horrible that the murders occurred. Just horrible. But I bet the neighbors are relieved to be rid of the brothers.

JB86 Dec 30, 2018 11:34 PM
Identities Released in Orcutt Triple Homicide

If it is true that this guy had a rifle, how did that happen given his 2014 felony conviction for domestic violence? Both State and Federal law prohibit possession of same by such a felon. So, what happened?

a-1566566100 Dec 31, 2018 09:41 AM
Identities Released in Orcutt Triple Homicide

@ PSTARSR You aware of the massive flaw in the old "laws don't prevent criminals from committing crimes" argument, aren't you? I mean, you are an adult with a fully developed brain, right?

PitMix Dec 31, 2018 09:25 AM
Identities Released in Orcutt Triple Homicide

Plenty of cases in the press where the local sheriff's dept fails to follow up on making sure the legal weapons are out of the perps hands. Remember the guy in Redding who was reported multiple times for firing weapons but the cops never pursued the reports- he ended up killing a bunch of people after that. And of course easy to get illegal weapons.

pstarSR Dec 31, 2018 07:44 AM
Identities Released in Orcutt Triple Homicide

criminals could never get there hands on a fire arm because someone told them not to, right? I mean just saying, "no you cant have that" works so well for children

a-1566566100 Dec 30, 2018 06:51 AM
Identities Released in Orcutt Triple Homicide

The father died earlier this year. He worked in the oil industry and had a construction business. I think he was well-liked. The suspect worked at Greka during the past year. Very sad.

a-1566566100 Dec 29, 2018 04:29 PM
Identities Released in Orcutt Triple Homicide

My prayers go out to the poor woman who was able to escape. She probably lost her family in this tragic act and saw more than she'll ever be able to forget.

a-1566566100 Dec 29, 2018 02:54 PM
Identities Released in Orcutt Triple Homicide

At some point in Chicago recent history, the murder rates on weekends were much much lower, and then multiplied exponentially. Seems there is a similarity, in that the numbers in Santa Maria/Orcutt could be the lowest they will be...and increase...too. Are we paying attention? Just closing our eyes, and hoping it will go away, or get better, is not a solution. It wasn't in Chicago.

a-1566566100 Dec 29, 2018 01:28 PM
Identities Released in Orcutt Triple Homicide

TAGDES, would you provide the link, I'm too lazy to search each month, although I did google it. Five shootings for that period seems low to me. Maybe I'm mixing up stabbings with shootings? Now I'm getting suspicious of my memory. I generally have the impression that Santa Maria is becoming less and less safe, but I'm open to having me be proved wrong.

tagdes Dec 29, 2018 07:45 PM
Identities Released in Orcutt Triple Homicide

It's all broken down monthly for you at their website. 2017 - 1 ea Aug, Sept & Dec and 2018 1 in Feb & 1 in Jun. Homicides which may include stabbings. The historical average is 3 a year. 2015 and 2016 were an exception with 13 and 9 respectively.

Roger Dec 29, 2018 02:06 PM
Identities Released in Orcutt Triple Homicide

In Chicago the figures are like 20 shot 7 dead it's like sports team stats every weekend this town is nothing compared to there go visit see for yourself.

tagdes Dec 29, 2018 01:21 PM
Identities Released in Orcutt Triple Homicide

As crazy as it may seem...Santa Maria does...and a few keystrokes show, 2017 Jan thru Dec total of 3 and for the first half of 2018, Jan thru Jun total of 2. Should be an update soon as this year is almost over.

a-1566566100 Dec 29, 2018 07:39 AM
Identities Released in Orcutt Triple Homicide

4 people dead. What's going on in Santa Maria/Orcutt area; is becoming like Chicago with so many shootings. What needs to be done there that is not currently being done? Santa Maria needs to clean up its mess. Pronto.

a-1566566100 Dec 29, 2018 06:55 AM
Identities Released in Orcutt Triple Homicide

Orcutt. 3 dead, shooter injured, hospital. Here's the Santa Maria Times: https://santamariatimes.com/news/local/crime-and-courts/three-found-dead-inside-orcutt-home-barricaded-suspect-shot-by/article_dda0b8f3-b110-53f3-8881-2757c454d7e6.html

Roger Dec 28, 2018 10:33 PM
Identities Released in Orcutt Triple Homicide

They were working on taking down the suspect with less lethal a bean bag shotgun I don't know if they were able to do that as someone yelled "Shots Fired!" as the take down occurred at least one victim is enroute to Marian Hospital...To recap at least 3 other victims were inside of the home one in the bathroom, 2 in the garage their conditions are unknown at this time...Sounds like they cleared the residence the area is still being checked...As for now this is Roger Dodger Over and Out...

Pages

Please Login or Register to comment on this.