Community Takes Mayor Murillo to Task for Inaction During Sunday's Protest

103 Comments
Reads 17932

Mayor Cathy Murillo kneeling during the virtual City Council meeting while saying the "Pledge of Allegiance"

By Lauren Bray, edhat staff

Nearly sixty community members held Santa Barbara Mayor Cathy Murillo accountable during public comment Tuesday for her refusal to kneel with protestors and listen to Black Lives Matter activists at a recent protest.

The virtual City Council meeting started with Murillo stating she would take a knee in honor of George Floyd during the Pledge of Allegiance before having a moment of silence.

"Mr. Floyd we are thinking of you and I pledge to do everything I can to reject and eliminate institutionalized racism in our society," said Murillo while praising Black Lives Matter and the NAACP. 

Floyd, an unarmed 46-year-old Black man, was murdered by four police officers last week in Minneapolis. He was handcuffed lying face down on a city street during an arrest while a white police officer kept his knee on Floyd's neck for 8 minutes and 46 seconds. He was later pronounced dead.

The murder sparked outrage that has rapidly spread throughout the United States, and eventually overseas, with marches, protests, and rallies. 

The local chapter of Black Lives Matter held a peaceful rally on Sunday against police brutality with approximately 3,000 attendees at the Santa Barbara County Courthouse. A march followed where protestors were faced with approximately twenty officers in full riot gear and an armored vehicle behind police tape in the 200 block of E. Figueroa Street, where the department is located.

Members of the Black community lying on the ground while supporters kneel in solidarity during Sunday's protest

Murillo stepped out from behind the police line and attempted to engage with protest leaders Simone Ruskamp and Krystle Farmer Sieghart. Murillo was asked to listen but attempted to talk over the two women.

During a peaceful demonstration where members of the Black community laid on the ground for 8 minutes and 46 seconds, the same amount of time Floyd was held on the ground, members of the non-black community were asked to kneel in solidarity. The crowd extended this offer to everyone behind the police tape, they all declined. 

Following the protest, Black Lives Matter Santa Barbara issued a set of demands asking for the protection and preservation of Black landmarks, transparency and accountability from local law enforcement, recognition of Juneteenth commemorating the Emancipation Proclamation, and the City Council adopts a resolution condemning police brutality and declares racism a public health emergency.

For over two hours of public comment on Tuesday, community members passionately expressed their disappointment with Murillo's lack of solidarity, empathy, and action. Some were high school students who cried while discussing the inequalities they face and how fearful they are of law enforcement.

Others called Murillo "tone-deaf" for issuing a press release following the protest. The statement, released on Murillo's behalf, recognized the death of Floyd and applauded Santa Barbara Police Chief Lori Luhnow for "courageous leadership," but failed to mention the peaceful protest, its leaders, and Black Lives Matter.

"We're going through a pandemic and we [brought] 3,000 of your constituents to stand with black lives, call out corruption and police brutality," said Sieghart. "Do your jobs, hold yourselves accountable for the harm caused in this community, do better."

Ruskamp called for the Mayor's resignation stating she was fine asking Black people to help get her elected but has been absent since her tenure. 

"Mayor, I expect you to resign, your actions have already spoken for you. You still have not reached out to either leader of the protest after you yelled in our faces and issued a statement and thanked the chief," said Ruskamp. "You all should be ashamed. The community is watching."

During the course of two hours, Murillo said few words beyond "thank you" and "next caller" between comments. 

Frustration and anger were also directed at Chief Luhnow for the presentation of officers in riot gear. Many expressed their fear of such a "militarized presence," while others wondered why the police responded in such a way when in previous protests officers assisted with traffic control and marched alongside protestors.

Santa Barbara Police in riot gear during a peaceful protest on Sunday

Several commenters urged the City Council to decrease funding to the police department and reject the proposal for a new police station while instead rerouting those funds to community services.

"Black people have been saying for centuries that the police are not safe, that institutions are not safe... you all saw with your own eyes what happened on Sunday. You saw that even as Black people laid down their bodies in front of the police in Santa Barbara, they continued to stand, and snicker, and intimidate," said Ruskamp in a Facebook video following the protest.

Chief Luhnow jumped into the virtual meeting to answer a question posed by Councilmember Alejandra Gutierrez who asked where she was and why officers were in riot gear.

"We've had officers in [Los Angeles] actively deployed in riots that have been violent. Our training dictates we wear extra gear when we do that. I'm not saying we saw that violence here, but I'm saying we can do better than we did," said Luhnow. "We're at our best when our community partners are with us and we're not trained to be in vulnerable positions but that is the learning that needs to occur."

Chief Luhnow continued to say she has the willingness to participate in acts of solidarity and will use this as an opportunity to listen and grow. She also stated she was returning to Santa Barbara and wasn't present for the protest while Murillo identified herself as the representative to speak with protestors. 

"I apologize if I could have done a better job and I certainly want to connect with [Ruskamp and Sieghart] as we go forward," said Murillo.

All city councilmembers expressed support for the protest and agreed to discuss the demands brought forth by the Black Lives Matter leaders.

Councilmember Kristen Sneddon said the protest was justified and didn't come from a singular tragedy, while vowing to listen and take action.

"Racism is a public health crisis, we are a part of the structural inequity... it's time for us to all acknowledge and act now for concrete change," she said.

Councilmember Meagan Harmon stated the demands were a gift the council didn't deserve and they provide a roadmap for how the city can stand with the Black community. 

"My job today... as an ally and councilmember is to amplify and elevate the voices of black leaders, black activists," said Harmon.

She specifically called out the creation of a civilian complaint review board stating she's advocated for this for many years and is committed to seeing this through. She additionally put forth an action item to make a change to council agenda reports to include socioeconomic impacts for each item. 

City Administrator Paul Casey said his team will be prepared to bring an agenda item to the council next week to discuss the demands.

One point all public commenters seemed to echo was that words are one thing, action is another, and they're watching and waiting.

Login to add Comments

103 Comments

Toggle Comments (Show)
kellyoshiro Jun 04, 2020 09:59 AM
Community Takes Mayor Murillo to Task for Inaction During Sunday's Protest

I started a petition for her resignation: http://chng.it/by77nJRcFF Dear Mayor Murillo, I voted for you in 2016 and I was excited to see the first Latina city mayor in the country. Your ability to win was built on years of hard work by the civil rights movement of the last 60 years. On Sunday, you didn't take a knee with protestors to share your support for the Black Lives Matter movement. How can you stand while the children, grandchildren and great-grandchildren of the protestors from the 60's take a knee? Ms. Mayor we are still fighting the same battle, why aren't you fighting? You need to resign immediately as Mayor of Santa Barbara. Sincerely, Kelly Oshiro

a-1594496382 Jun 04, 2020 09:12 AM
Community Takes Mayor Murillo to Task for Inaction During Sunday's Protest

Santa Barbara Police need to BAN chokeholds and strangleholds, require de-escalation, require exhausting other means before shooting, implement a duty to intervene, ban shooting at moving vehicles, and have use of Force Continuum. By implementing and following these measures, it's been proven police violence can decrease by 72%.

Shasta Guy Jun 04, 2020 08:54 AM
Community Takes Mayor Murillo to Task for Inaction During Sunday's Protest

How many people woke up to find flyers on their windshields with a clenched fist and a code to scan? No website given. At least they didn’t put them in cars in driveways. It happened in the middle of the night which means some activist group is canvassing neighborhoods. This was near Roosevelt School.

Bene Jun 04, 2020 12:29 AM
Community Takes Mayor Murillo to Task for Inaction During Sunday's Protest

I don't fault Murillo for not bending a knee. Maybe she has arthritis. If so, all that bending and groveling around in the dirt is harder than it looks. And then there’s this—it kind of looks off-message when you think about it. A proud man or woman of color does not bend a knee to anyone. “Taking a knee” has some pretty heavy symbolism from pretty much the dawn of time, if one remembers time prior to Kapernack-- and it’s not good symbolism. Bending a knee reminds some of us of the subjugation of our ancestors. One can do a lot of useful actions to help, without doing the bending thing. Actually, maybe it's time the movement got a new and more appropriate symbol to show support. Besides it’s not very sanitary really, all that groveling around in the dirt.

mp805 Jun 03, 2020 10:09 PM
Community Takes Mayor Murillo to Task for Inaction During Sunday's Protest

Black Lives Matter wants to defund law enforcement and reinvest that money into the black communities. Black Lives Matter co-founder Patrisse Cullors says only “radical shifts” can stop law enforcement violence. While she understands the desire to hold individual officers accountable for their actions, Cullors says the demand to defund law enforcement and reinvest the money in black communities is what can achieve justice for black Americans.

a-1594496382 Jun 04, 2020 12:10 AM
Community Takes Mayor Murillo to Task for Inaction During Sunday's Protest

He's been doing an exceptionally fine job all the way through this: daily press briefings, with the press asking tough questions, and in Spanish and English. This program tonight was a big announcement, along with his police commission announcing reforms. Compare that to our lame mayor...who was invisible for 2 months in this disaster, all the way through the Debris Flow, and can't handle interactions or press.

reloadSB Jun 03, 2020 06:19 PM
Community Takes Mayor Murillo to Task for Inaction During Sunday's Protest

www.santabarbaraca.gov/gov/depts/police/policies/ As to the next town hall and the purpose of such meeting I cannot speak to that. I do know that Santa Barbara Police Department and the Sheriff's Department offer their citizens academy that help educate the public on what their job entails.

reloadSB Jun 03, 2020 05:02 PM
Community Takes Mayor Murillo to Task for Inaction During Sunday's Protest

This is just pure laziness and attempting to construct a false narrative. SB City's "Use of Force Policy" has been on the Santa Barbara Police Departments Website for years. Not only that, their entire policy manual, their Field Training Manual and all other training updates are available. Instead of suggesting that something is being hidden, look in plain sight.

a-1594496382 Jun 03, 2020 01:16 PM
Community Takes Mayor Murillo to Task for Inaction During Sunday's Protest

I hope these protests really bring some change. Many black owned businesses are in economically challenged areas which often exist due to racism. I hope to see more people paying attention to economically depressed or challenged areas where there are black owned businesses struggling, or to areas with high black populations with smaller businesses, and start to bring there business there, So often I see people avoiding those areas b/c they think they are "high crime" [another example of stereotypes] and the discrimination just perpetuates itself. This has to change. WE need to empower these disenfranchised communities and start to patronize them. SB is a bit of a bubble and I hope to see people doing more of this.

Bene Jun 04, 2020 12:40 AM
Community Takes Mayor Murillo to Task for Inaction During Sunday's Protest

Exactly how would you address lack of diversity in SB--realistically? I walked in a beautiful neighborhood the other day. Boy sure wish I could live there. But what am I gonna do? Have those people dragged out of their homes and put me in it? Believe me, even with tons of money most of us aren't getting our butts in one of those homes. The good ones are rarely for sale. People with the good real estate here bought a long time ago and they aren't generally budging. This is a small area sandwiched between mountains and ocean. And nature isn't making any more land.

a-1594496382 Jun 03, 2020 02:28 PM
Community Takes Mayor Murillo to Task for Inaction During Sunday's Protest

M_CUBE you're kidding right? As of 2020: According to the most recent ACS, the racial composition of Santa Barbara was: White: 79.59% Other race: 10.83% Asian: 3.86% Two or more races: 3.59% Black or African American: 1.30% Native American: 0.68% Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander: 0.16% Take a ride on the upper east side, the riviera, mission canyon, Montecito and other wealthier areas of SB and let me know how many minorities you see living there. Ask yourself, why is it mostly whites? What bothers you about this truth? The largest minority here is hispanic and they mostly live in what people consider the less desirable poorer areas of town [I actually prefer those areas]. Please!

a-1594496382 Jun 03, 2020 02:15 PM
Community Takes Mayor Murillo to Task for Inaction During Sunday's Protest

Exactly my point, maybe not as well stated. This goes way deeper than a black box on social media and kneeling. All that is great but, this has to be addressed too. Why are there proportionately way more whites in SB? Among other questions. I went to school in what was considered a "high crime" [and mostly black] city and I had no problems.

a-1594496382 Jun 03, 2020 02:10 PM
Community Takes Mayor Murillo to Task for Inaction During Sunday's Protest

"So often I see people avoiding those areas b/c they think they are "high crime" [another example of stereotypes] and the discrimination just perpetuates itself."............Have to agree with you with the stereotypes, because the exact opposite is true: Cities and neighborhoods with traditionally high black populations are quite safe and do not experience high crime (as stereotypes would suggest).

a-1594496382 Jun 03, 2020 01:27 PM
Community Takes Mayor Murillo to Task for Inaction During Sunday's Protest

For example, will SB people start heading into LA and other areas to frequent those businesses now? Especially as many have been hard hit by COVID and now rioting and looting? I would hope that would be the case. I see people avoiding those areas b/c they are afraid of them. Will this change now? Hope so.

Lorax Jun 03, 2020 12:50 PM
Community Takes Mayor Murillo to Task for Inaction During Sunday's Protest

As Santa Barbara stands in solidarity and sadness , we are all closer than some would think and stand united against racism. I want to commend Mayor Murillo for the courage to directly approach the crowd on State St. What I saw was compassion, leadership and a direct attempt to communicate with the organizers from a hands on Mayor. Obviously in the midst of all the Covid tension and adrenaline of the crowd, her well intended motive was clearly misunderstood. I commend Mayor Murillo's leadership and sensitivity and am proud to live in such a caring community.

a-1594496382 Jun 03, 2020 11:34 AM
Community Takes Mayor Murillo to Task for Inaction During Sunday's Protest

"The murder sparked outrage that has rapidly spread throughout the United States, and eventually overseas, with marches, protests, and rallies." ............and riots.......and more murders......and looting (important side note: no book stores were looted).....and beatings...and destruction......and mayhem....smashings.....bashings.....violence.....hate.... and someone wants the mayor to kneel. Riiiiiight-eee---oh then.....

a-1594496382 Jun 03, 2020 11:29 AM
Community Takes Mayor Murillo to Task for Inaction During Sunday's Protest

George Floyd was murdered by knee to the neck; racism is alive and well in America and in too many police departments. Our police department should not be painted with the same racist label as some other departments in our country. They do a great job protecting the public with limited resources and fairly treat our people. In 2016, 232 blacks were killed in the US by police and far too many were killed under questionable circumstances. Police killings of blacks need to be addressed on a national level. Police committing illegal killing of blacks, offenders or not, need to be brought to justice and punished. Blacks have an even bigger issue that also needs to be addressed by them because they are the only people who can reduce the numbers. In rounded figures from FBI statistics for the year 2016, 2,900 blacks were murdered in the USA and they were murdered by 2,600 blacks or 90%. This shows that in 2016 alone, blacks killed over ten times of their own than police did.

Roger Jun 03, 2020 10:43 AM
Community Takes Mayor Murillo to Task for Inaction During Sunday's Protest

I know there were rumors flying around that Antifa might show up and there would be trouble though the Organizers of the protest and representatives of Black Lives Matter had no intentions of starting trouble the Police Department were being cautious and part of that caution is protecting the Mayor..I believe there is alot of Fear on both sides of this fence and Education is the Key to ending the fear everyone just needs to slow down and take a moment here. All of us are equal we all belong here we need to figure out how to get along here. The Mayor should not resign because she made a mistake in judgement put down your torches and pitchforks the powers that be acted responsibly....

SantaBarbaraObserver Jun 04, 2020 09:11 AM
Community Takes Mayor Murillo to Task for Inaction During Sunday's Protest

Antifa doesnt exist outside the paranoid delusional minds of the far right. There is no org. There is no group. There are no professional protestors. They are a figment of the authoritarian's imagination created to scare the weak minded and meek. Its truly amazing how gullible the far right is, isnt it? -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- If you're in America and you're not antifascist, you are not American. Our grandfathers were anti fascists, they went to Europe and the So Pacific to fight them... I am anti fascist and I will fight fascism to my death. Every real, patriotic American is antifascist. If you're not anti-fascist, then you are Pro-Fascist. Are you pro fascism? Are you pro dictator? Are you pro-oppression?

ginger1 Jun 03, 2020 11:24 AM
Community Takes Mayor Murillo to Task for Inaction During Sunday's Protest

City council is not about partisan politics. Dem, Rep, Lib, Ind---doesn't matter. City council is supposed to be about us, about neighborhood representation. That is why we moved to district/neighborhood elections, to assure more reasonable and fair representation for all of our citizens. It's about giving a voice to our people. Our elected officials are mostly very new to the job. (We can discuss failures by city staff later.) We need to work with them and if they do not represent the will of the community, they get voted out. Asking immediately for their resignation is not the right path. They should have the opportunity to make things right, to learn and correct their errors. If those errors/policies place the community at risk, then waiting for the election cycle is waiting too long and they should be asked to step down. Guitierrez, Murillo and Luhnow should be given a day to reflect on the consequences of their actions (or inactions.) and to make amends. This is not the only issue for which the major or a city councilmember has taken a stance in conflict with what should have been. Remember that at the next election. If you think you can do better, organize your neighbors and try to get elected and serve your community. If you want to have the power to make change, don't just blog about it.

a-1594496382 Jun 03, 2020 10:57 AM
Community Takes Mayor Murillo to Task for Inaction During Sunday's Protest

@Roger, you're wrong. These rumors were STARTED by the police. And if they were so concerned someone was going to hijack the peaceful rally, why weren't they there? I walked the entire perimeter of the rally and moved through the crowd and the only person I saw was Anthony Wagner (SBPD PIO) standing in the middle of the really with his cellphone acting like a CIA agent. There were 3 cops on bicycles across the street sitting in the shade doing nothing. If cops were that fearful of something awful and angry, be there to PROTECT THE PEOPLE. Instead they chose to protect their own headquarters and make a military demonstration of their force and power. The protest leaders and attendees were peaceful the entire time, there was no fear on that side.

Pages

Please Login or Register to comment on this.